Thread: Recommendations:: First Stephan Feld game
by pwhy5 I have heard a lot of good things about Stephan Feld's designs and my choice has been narrowed down to The Castles of Burgundy, Macao, The year of the dragon and Trajan.Out of those three,...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by Eeeville I've played Burgundy, ITYOTD, and Macao. I rank them as such: Burgundy > ITYOTD >>>>>>> MacaoBurgundy is also the highest rated game of the lot. Macao is the...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by pfctsqr Eeeville wrote:I've played Burgundy, ITYOTD, and Macao. I rank them as such: Burgundy > ITYOTD >>>>>>> MacaoBurgundy is also the highest rated game of the lot. Macao...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by thedacker Eeeville wrote:I've played Burgundy, ITYOTD, and Macao. I rank them as such Burgundy > ITYOTD >>>>>>> MacaoBurgundy is also the highest rated game of the lot....
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by thedacker Eeeville wrote:Trajan is best with 4 exactly, and ITYOTD is best with 4 - 5.I've played Trajan with 2 a lot, and it's fantastic.
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by Eric Brosius For me, it's like this:Notre Dame > ITYOTD > Macao >>>> Burgund > TrajanI would sit out rather than play Trajan again.I would consider playing Burgund if someone...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by casualgod Macao is my favorite Feld game, but I will second what has been said before. It seems to be one of his more polarizing games and Burgundy seems to get more requests for play. The people I...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by dsant Trajan >>>> Macao >> Burgundy >> Notre Dame > ItYotD >> RomaTrajan is Feld's masterpiece, in my opinion. Macao and Burgundy are both great games, but I prefer...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by aaarg_ink casualgod wrote:Macao is my favorite Feld game, but I will second what has been said before. It seems to be one of his more polarizing games and Burgundy seems to get more requests for...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by voynitsky I'll come in with a different suggestion, The Speicherstadt. It's one of his more simple games, but that's what makes it so good. It does one thing, auctions, and does it very very...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by dsant Speich is a great auction game, but unlike any of his others, IMO. Luna is a very brain-burning perfect information game. Both are good as well.
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by mfaulk80 Eeeville wrote:I've played Burgundy, ITYOTD, and Macao. I rank them as such: Burgundy > ITYOTD >>>>>>> MacaoBurgundy is also the highest rated game of the lot....
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by bchlax944 Eeeville wrote:I've played Burgundy, ITYOTD, and Macao. I rank them as such: Burgundy > ITYOTD >>>>>>> MacaoBurgundy is also the highest rated game of the lot....
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by pwhy5 Right now, I am mostly looking for a 2-3 player game. If we are 4-5, I have many other games I'd rather play.This is why Castles caught my attention in the first place as it plays well with 2...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by Eeeville pwhy5 wrote:It would be The Castles of Burgundy, right?Seems like it, but I consider Troyes to be a much better game than Burgundy.
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by Dormammu I'd start with Notre Dame or The Speicherstadt.
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by thedacker pwhy5 wrote:So....for a 2-3 player game, which is not stricly 2 players (I play Memoir 44 for that) with a lot of strategy and managing to reduce luck of the dice by cleverly picking the...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by dkearns I love Macao but I recommend starting with Notre Dame.
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by bchlax944 Trajan is the most strategic game of those mentioned. Burgundy is close as well. Both offer a lot of fun game play with deep strategy.
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: First Stephan Feld game
by she2 bchlax944 wrote:Frankly all Stefan feld games save itYotD are best with 2 and maybe 3. While I like Macao a lot with 2p, I don't agree it's necessarily best with 2. There is an added aspect to...
View Article
